Kapolei development ‘cranking’ 40 – Pacific Business News

Appraisals for former Hawaii Navy bunkers should help buyers seeking financing



The first appraisals have come in for the Waikele Storage Park, clearing the way for buyers to seek conventional financing for the former Navy bunkers-turned-fee-simple industrial condominiums carved out of the mountains around Kipapa Gulch and parcels of land around them.

Developer Peter Savio first offered the 125 bunkers for sale two years ago with 99-year ground leases, but then he bought the fee to the 515 acres of land in late 2016 from Hunt Cos., which had acquired the former Waikele Naval Magazine from the Navy.

Appraiser Chris Ponsar of Ponsar Valuation said it was initially a challenge to appraise the storage bunkers because the unique nature of the property presented several uncertainties to lenders — the land initially wasn’t fee simple, the condominium documents had not been completed and there was some uncertainty about the permitted uses.

But since Savio closed on the purchase of the land, all that has been cleared up, and the use of the land, most of which is zoned preservation, has been established as strictly storage.

“The main issue is when you’re talking about the bunkers, the bunkers are use restricted for storage,” Ponsar said. “That makes them different from traditional industrial condos. That makes it challenging to appraise because there’s not many things on the market.”

Because the land is preservation land, the property’s use is restricted to its previous use by the military, which was for storage. When Savio took over management of the property as the master lessor under Hunt, he leased the properties out to a variety of small businesses for storage, including Waikele Self Storage.

Buyers who had purchased 11 bunkers and some 150,000 square feet of land under the ground lease provisions for a discount were then converted to fee simple.

But those transactions were all cash — without the fee, or comparables, banks were hesitant to lend on the project, said Mark Ambard of Ambard & Co., who is marketing the units along with brokers from Savio Realty Ltd.

Currently, a total of 14 bunkers and 180,000 square feet of land have been recorded as fee-simple transactions, he said. Another 42 units and 275 square feet of land are under contract, which includes 23 units being bought by Waikele Self Storage.

The remaining bunkers are being offered for sale for $350,000, which includes the 4,000 square feet of storage plus an outside loading dock and loading area.

“Once the market digests the fact that much of the risk that has been associated with the project is gone, I think the future is bright for the project,” Ponsar said.

Welcome to the Ponsar Valuation Blog!


It is with great pleasure that we announce the launch of Ponsar Valuation LLC and welcome all to the home of the Ponsar Valuation Blog!

Here you will find entries covering a range of topics essential to the Hawaii real estate community and appraisal industry. Stay tuned – there is more to come!…

A personal note from Chris Ponsar:

As we launch, I would like to extend a sincere thank you and warm aloha to The Hallstrom Group | CBRE family/team, with whom I worked shoulder to shoulder for nearly 15 years.

I would especially like to convey my heartfelt thanks to Jim Hallstrom, MAI, CRE, FRICS for his genuine mentorship and invaluable guidance over the years, and Tom Holliday, CRE, FRICS (aka “Uncle Tom”) for exposing me to the appraisal profession when I was a teenager and introducing me to The Hallstrom Group in 2002.  Without the amazingly generous support of Jim and Uncle Tom, there is no Ponsar Valuation–these are debts my family and I cannot repay.

Thank you!